Tuesday, 25 March 2008

Why support Palestine but ignore Tibet?

The great Dennis Prager makes a reasonable point. Why is it that Palestine attracts so much support from the UN, international media and leftist organisations when there's a much more valid case for supporting Tibet against China?
The long-suffering Tibetans have been in the news. This happens perhaps once or twice a decade. In a more moral world, however, public opinion would be far more preoccupied with Tibetans than with Palestinians, would be as harsh on China as it is on Israel, and would be as fawning on Israel as it now is on China.

But, alas, the world is, as it has always been, a largely mean-spirited and morally insensitive place, where might is far more highly regarded than right.

Consider the facts: Tibet, at least 1,400 years old, is one of the world's oldest nations, has its own language, its own religion and even its own ethnicity. Over 1 million of its people have been killed by the Chinese, its culture has been systematically obliterated, 6,000 of its 6,200 monasteries have been looted and destroyed, and most of its monks have been tortured, murdered or exiled.

Palestinians have none of these characteristics. There has never been a Palestinian country, never been a Palestinian language, never been a Palestinian ethnicity, never been a Palestinian religion in any way distinct from Islam elsewhere. Indeed, "Palestinian" had always meant any individual living in the geographic area called Palestine. For most of the first half of the 20th century, "Palestinian" and "Palestine" almost always referred to the Jews of Palestine. The United Jewish Appeal, the worldwide Jewish charity that provided the nascent Jewish state with much of its money, was actually known as the United Palestine Appeal. Compared to Tibetans, few Palestinians have been killed, its culture has not been destroyed nor its mosques looted or plundered, and Palestinians have received billions of dollars from the international community. Unlike the dying Tibetan nation, there are far more Palestinians today than when Israel was created.

None of this means that a distinct Palestinian national identity does not now exist. Since Israel's creation such an identity has arisen and does indeed exist. Nor does any of this deny that many Palestinians suffered as a result of the creation of the third Jewish state in the area, known -- since the Romans renamed Judea -- as "Palestine."

But it does mean that of all the causes the world could have adopted, the Palestinians' deserved to be near the bottom and the Tibetans' near the top. This is especially so since the Palestinians could have had a state of their own from 1947 on, and they have caused great suffering in the world, while the far more persecuted Tibetans have been characterized by a morally rigorous doctrine of nonviolence.

So, the question is, why? Why have the Palestinians received such undeserved attention and support, and the far more aggrieved and persecuted and moral Tibetans given virtually no support or attention?

The first reason is terror. Some time ago, the Palestinian leadership decided, with the overwhelming support of the Palestinian people, that murdering as many innocent people -- first Jews, and then anyone else -- was the fastest way to garner world attention. They were right. On the other hand, as The Economist notes in its March 28, 2008 issue, "Tibetan nationalists have hardly ever resorted to terrorist tactics…" It is interesting to speculate how the world would have reacted had Tibetans hijacked international flights, slaughtered Chinese citizens in Chinese restaurants and temples, on Chinese buses and trains, and massacred Chinese schoolchildren.

The second reason is oil and support from powerful fellow Arabs. The Palestinians have rich friends who control the world's most needed commodity, oil. The Palestinians have the unqualified support of all Middle Eastern oil-producing nations and the support of the Muslim world beyond the Middle East. The Tibetans are poor and have the support of no nations, let alone oil-producing ones.

The third reason is Israel. To deny that pro-Palestinian activism in the world is sometimes related to hostility toward Jews is to deny the obvious. It is not possible that the unearned preoccupation with the Palestinians is unrelated to the fact that their enemy is the one Jewish state in the world. Israel's Jewishness is a major part of the Muslim world's hatred of Israel. It is also part of Europe's hostility toward Israel: Portraying Israel as oppressors assuages some of Europe's guilt about the Holocaust -- "see, the Jews act no better than we did." Hence the ubiquitous comparisons of Israel to Nazis.

A fourth reason is China. If Tibet had been crushed by a white European nation, the Tibetans would have elicited far more sympathy. But, alas, their near-genocidal oppressor is not white. And the world does not take mass murder committed by non-whites nearly as seriously as it takes anything done by Westerners against non-Westerners. Furthermore, China is far more powerful and frightening than Israel. Israel has a great army and nuclear weapons, but it is pro-West, it is a free and democratic society, and it has seven million people in a piece of land as small as Belize. China has nuclear weapons, has a trillion U.S. dollars, an increasingly mighty army and navy, is neither free nor democratic, is anti-Western, and has 1.2 billion people in a country that dominates the Asian continent.

A fifth reason is the world's Left. As a general rule, the Left demonizes Israel and has loved China since it became Communist in 1948. And given the power of the Left in the world's media, in the political life of so many nations, and in the universities and the arts, it is no wonder vicious China has been idolized and humane Israel demonized.

The sixth reason is the United Nations, where Israel has been condemned in more General Assembly and Security Council resolutions than any other country in the world. At the same time, the UN has voted China onto its Security Council and has never condemned it. China's sponsoring of Sudan and its genocidal acts against its non-Arab black population, as in Darfur, goes largely unremarked on at the UN, let alone condemned, just as is the case with its cultural genocide, ethnic cleansing and military occupation of Tibet.

The seventh reason is television news, the primary source of news for much of mankind. Aside from its leftist tilt, television news reports only what it can video. And almost no country is televised as much as Israel, while video reports in Tibet are forbidden, as they are almost anywhere in China except where strictly monitored by the Chinese authorities. No video, no TV news. And no TV, no concern. So while grieving Palestinians and the accidental killings of Palestinians during morally necessary Israeli retaliations against terrorists are routinely televised, the slaughter of over a million Tibetans and the extinguishing of Tibetan Buddhism and culture are non-events as far as television news is concerned.

The world is unfair, unjust and morally twisted. And rarely more so than in its support for the Palestinians -- no matter how many innocents they target for murder and no matter how much Nazi-like anti-Semitism permeates their media -- and its neglect of the cruelly treated, humane Tibetans.
To those who think that the issues in Palestine are created by the Israelis you should seek the answer to a question. Why is it that if you live in Gaza or the West Bank then you cannot migrate to any other Arab country (with only a couple of exceptions)?

Here are some possible answers:

A) Hamas (Gaza) or Fatah (West Bank) do not allow it;
B) You are too poor to migrate; or
C) Other Arab countries do not allow you to migrate to them.

(Nothing Follows)

7 comments:

T Wong said...

Why don't you white people get the hell off of native land in North and South America and go back to Europe? Maybe then you will have the right to point fingers at China. White people are the worst abusers of human rights in the history of the world. Besides committing genocide on native American peoples and placing the few straggling survivors onto "reservations", besides enslaving Africans, besides colonializing nearly all non-white nations throughout the world, impoverishing them and leading to the development of third world nations, besides being the first and only ones to ever massacre innocent civilians using nuclear weaponry, besides being responsible for Apartheid, besides causing the extinction of thousands of species and worldwide pollution dating back to the Industrial Revolution and continuing with the U.S., the world's biggest polluter which also failed to ratify the Kyoto Treaty, besides continuing to discriminate against minorities within their own borders, besides being responsible for the Holocaust, you people continue to abuse, you continue to occupy land of other peoples, from Australia to Canada to the United States. Go back to Europe if you want Chinese people to get out of Tibet, or else shut your bigoted hypocritical self-righteous mouth.

hoppers said...

Fabulous and most enjoyable rant Mr (Mrs? Ms?) Wong, but I suspect you have missed the point that the blogger was trying to make.

Jack Lacton said...

If I made a list of atrocities carried out by the Chinese then they would differ from Mr T Wong's list by 1) being true and 2) being about a hundred times as long.

Mr Wong does win the most insane comment posted here for a long while award, though.

chenlina said...

chenlina20160521
gucci handbags
oakley vault
coach outlet store online
burberry scarf
jordan retro 3
cheap jordan shoes
michael kors handbags
michael kors
burberry outlet
kobe 9
christian louboutin sale
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
air jordans
rolex watches
giuseppe zanotti
kevin durant shoes 7
nike uk
nike free runs
north face outlet
michael kors outlet online
toms wedges
ray ban sunglasses
air jordans
toms outlet
michael kors handbags
hollister
coach factory outlet
jordan 13
polo ralph lauren outlet
burberry bags
oakley sunglasses outlet
air jordans
coach factory outlet
louis vuitton handbags
caoch outlet
michael kors uk
louis vuitton outlet
ray ban sunglasses
gucci outlet
as

Zhenhong Bao said...

toms outlet
tiffany jewellery
beats headphones
oakley sunglasses wholesale
ray-ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses wholesale
michael kors uk
rolex watches
gucci sunglasses uk
michael kors outlet store
michael kors outlet
fitflops sale clearance
prada sunglasses for women
michael kors outlet
dior sunglasses
rolex uk
ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet
lululemon outlet
longchamp pas cher
camisetas futbol baratas
ferragamo outlet
air force 1 shoes
louis vuitton sunglasses for women
police sunglasses
futbol baratas
reebok shoes
louis vuitton handbags outlet
cartier watches
cheap nba jerseys
prada handbags
versace sunglasses
polo ralph lauren
jordan pas cher
ray-ban sunglasses
20160531zhenhong

chenzhen said...

louis vuitton purse
yeezy boost 350 balck
nike force 1
coach outlet online
nike running shoes
mizuno running shoes
adidas pure boost black
michael kors canada
michael kors bags
jordan pas cher
north face jackets
nike cortez white
cheap ray bans
michael kors outlet online
oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglass,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglasses cheap,oakley sunglasses outlet,oakley store,oakley outlet,oakley outlet store,oakley sunglasses sale,oakley sunglasses discount
louis vuitton purse
nike air force
nike air max 90
tiffany uk
tiffany and co outlet
ralph lauren pas cher
birkenstocks
new balance shoes
louis vuitton uk
true religion
christian louboutin shoes
adidas supercolor pink
michael kors handbags outlet
michael kors handbags
coach outlet online
stephen curry basketball shoes
nike shoes for cheap
adidas nmd black
jordans
michael kors outlet
ray ban outlet store
coach factory outlet
adidas nmd uk
chenzhen2016628

xjd7410@gmail.com said...

oakley sunglasses
fit flops
kate spade handbags
air force 1
jordan retro 11
michael kors outlet clearance
cheap jordans
polo ralph kids
ed hardy outlet
louis vuitton outlet
toms wedges
oakley sunglasses outlet
coach outlet
nike air max uk
louis vuitton outlet
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton purses
ralph lauren
copy watches
jordan 3 white cenment
louis vuitton bags
tods outlet online
true religion outlet
michael kors handbags
lebron 12
instyler max
retro 11
coach factory outlet online
ralph lauren outlet
chenyingying201670801